Sept. 5, 2026
The Harsh Truth About Pete Alonso And The Hall Of Fame
Pete Alonso has delivered plenty of home runs and memorable moments—but is he really a Hall of Famer?
In this episode, Bob Walters explains why Alonso's career résumé falls short of Cooperstown and why the Mets made the right decision by refusing to commit to a five-year contract last offseason. It may have been an unpopular move, but was it the correct baseball decision?
Listen now and decide for yourself: Did the Mets make the right call?
Apple Podcasts 
Spotify 
Castro 
RSS Feed 
Amazon Music 
YouTube
- Why home-run totals alone don’t make Alonso a Hall of Famer
- How his complete career résumé compares with Cooperstown expectations
- The difference between being a popular slugger and an all-time great
- Why a five-year commitment carried significant risk for the Mets
- The danger of paying for past production
- Why the Mets made the responsible long-term decision
- Did emotion and fan loyalty overshadow the baseball argument?
- What Alonso would still need to accomplish to change the Hall of Fame conversation
Tell us what you think . Don’t forget to leave a review.